Next Generation Luminaires Design Competition

Evaluation Criteria

The judges scored each entry on the following set of criteria:

  • Color appearance - Evaluation of this criterion will be based on the judging panel's evaluation of the color appearance of the installed luminaire. CCT data must be provided through LM-79-08 testing reports. CCT of finalists will be verified through LM-79-08 testing as necessary.
  • Color rendering - Evaluation of this criterion will be based on the judging panel's evaluation of the color appearance of objects illuminated by the installed luminaire. CRI data must be provided through LM-79-08 testing reports. CRI of finalists will be verified through LM-79-08 testing as necessary.
  • Appropriate illuminance - Horizontal and/or vertical illuminance for the application must be appropriate according to accepted lighting practice. Evaluation of this criterion will be based on the judging panel's evaluation of the light levels and distribution (uniformity and contrast) provided by the luminaire, and may also include measurement of light levels using a standard illuminance meter.
  • Appropriate luminance - This criterion addresses luminance of the luminaire surface. Judges will evaluate luminaire brightness in conditions as similar as possible to the intended application to assess glare and contrast. Photometric luminance of the luminaire will be verified through LM-79-08 testing of finalists as necessary.
  • Application effectiveness - The luminaire must deliver appropriate light levels to the task with lower wattage than comparable traditional light sources for that task. Evaluation of this criterion will be based on assessment by the judging panel.
  • Aesthetic appearance and style - Evaluation of this criterion will be based on the judging panel's subjective evaluation of the aesthetic appearance of the installed luminaire.
  • Serviceability and replacement - Entries must demonstrate attention to specifier and user concerns about follow-on service and replacement in the event of component failure.

The judging panel awarded bonus points for entries exhibiting desirable characteristics. Bonus points were available for the attributes listed below:

  • No off-state power use - luminaire designs that do not draw power when the luminaire is turned off. Consistent with ENERGY STAR® SSL requirements, up to 0.5 W of off-state power draw is allowed for luminaires with integral occupancy, motion, photo-controls, or individually addressable luminaires with external control and intelligence.
  • Dark-sky friendly - outdoor luminaires that are shielded to limit upward light emission, and minimize sky glow and light trespass. This criterion is especially useful in evaluating outdoor luminaires; it includes ratings by lighting zone for backlight, uplight, and glare (BUG rating).
  • Adjustability/Flexibility - products that demonstrate white light and beam spread adjustability.
  • Other bonus points were awarded at the discretion of the judging panel.

Indoor Competitions

Past Competitions

 

Timeline

NGL Judging Process
Behind the Scenes Videos

2015 Competition

2014 Competition

Questions?

Please send questions to: .

Competition Partners